Originally Posted by: HK1837 And it says Holden model, and LH Torana isn't a Holden model, it might be marketed as a Holden Torana but it isn't a Holden model. Or it could be argued it is the first Torana to actually be seen as a Holden, as prior to that the Toranas were 82x model codes, and all Holdens (or Statesmans) wore 80x or 81x model codes.
I understand the argument but I'm still not a fan of the Holden Lion thing though, a HQ-HZ Deville has a Holden Lion in its badges (where the Caprice wears I think the Cadillac badges), although if you ordered a Caprice with factory fitted XW5 outback equipment package you'd get mudflaps factory fitted with a Holden Lion on them. The flip side of the coin Statesmans have a Lion on their BODY plate whereas the import/rebadges and exports don't get the Lion and to me a CKD Impala or Parisienne or even a Chevy or Bedford truck assembled locally has a lot more local content and a lot more GMH involvement that some of the other imported stuff sporting a Holden badge or a Holden Lion. You have to draw the line somewhere though!
I believe that this "What is a Holden & what isn't a Holden" thing needs a re-visit.
IMHO Holden morphed from being simply the name of a car model to being a manufacturer (or marque) in the 1967-68 period.
Up until then there was only one car-line, which was called a Holden which was built by the manufacturer, GM-H.
If somebody said to you in say 1964 that they had just purchased a new "Holden" you knew exactly what they meant, it was an EH.
GM-H added a second model line in 1967, the Torana range. It was badged a Holden & advertised as a Holden & the brochures were all titled Holden Torana.
Then in 1968, the HK range had each & every model badged individually, from the Belmont right thru to the Brougham. There was no separate model called a Holden.
So in 1968-70, If you went to a GM-H dealer to purchase a new Holden, you would be shown anything from a Torana, Kingwood, Premier, Monaro, Brougham or whatever.
In they eyes of the average Joe public this range equated to Fords range of Cortina, Falcon, Fairmont, Fairlane etc. There was no separate car just called a Ford, as there had been decades earlier.
OK, they muddied the waters firstly but segregating the Statesman as being not from Holden, but being a GM product & then releasing the HJ base commercial range without badges. This last thing to me is a bit like the Chrysler by Chrysler model in the early 70s, where Chrysler was the manufacturer, but was also the model.
You would have to agree that today, where the company has actually been titled Holden, in various ways since the financial crisis of 1985, that Holden is now the marque, not just a single car.
Even today we have the rather silly situation where the Commodore ute is not badged a Commodore, so is just a Holden, does not mean that the name Holden is not the marque.
Your thoughts.
Dr Terry
Originally Posted by: HK1837 I think you are right on the VC, it is purposely called a HOLDEN Commodore and if HDT wasn't recognised as a manufacturer at that stage then it is a Bathurst 1000 winning Holden. Not sure how 1986 VK and 1987 VL fit into the equation either, as from what I understand Holden had to market and sell the VL and VN Group A SS as a Holden car, not as a HSV in order to make them eligible for international Group A rules where a manufacturer had to build so many cars (5000 from memory) then another 500 evolutional cars (the Group A's). So not sure how that all worked for VK and VL for the 1986-1987 races.
Group A rules stipulated that a minimum of 5000 identical cars had to be built & sold to be eligible to race. A further 500 "evolution models' could then be released, but they had to be built by the same manufacturer. You couldn't have the situation where Holden built 5000 Commodores & then have HDT or HSV modify (or build) the 500 evolution models. Holden' had to be the maker, even it was under contract to a third party. These were FIA world rules that CAMS had to follow to the letter.
AFAIK the four different SS Group A Commodores, VK, VL (A9L), VL (XV2) & the VN are all official Holden models with appropriate workshop manuals issued, unlike all other HDT/HSV stuff.
Prior to Group A, we had Group C, which administered by CAMS was much less rigid & the fact that HDT models were raced as Holdens, didn't really matter.
Dr Terry