Originally Posted by: Dr Terry I can't understand all of the dramas today with running in flat tappet cams.
I spent over 25 years building engines, mainly Holden 6, V8 & SBC & have never had an issue.
I also knew of many guys who never even bothered to run them in & also rarely had problems.
What has changed ? The metal hardness of the lifter base ? Higher valve spring pressures ? Lack of zinc in the oil ?
Dr Terry
Maybe it's just fatigue a old Holden red Cam could be 57yo now.
I have been warning people about that they must be using the correct oil for the flat bottom now for years but they just do not listen, they have come to me and said what is this problem from, lifters and Cam lobes totally rooted.
They claim Oh they use the best oil brand and full syn. No! that is not the point at all. the flat bottom lifter needs Zinc etc and only because of ADR laws was such taken out of oil because they claim Zinc can eat out the cat converter.
I like flat bottom lifters batter than roller lifters and all the problems that can come about from that crap. Them Gen 3 plastic lifter buckets are shit ! make sure you replace them with good quality ones, the early ones are crap, but if you are changing a Cam do not use the old buckets at all toss them, or you will destroy the roller lifter.
Roller lifters were a big problem with Mobil 1 full synthetic that I seen, then they changed that oil later down the track to improve it, I believe that the first type oil did not roll the lifters roller and this put pressure on one side of the roller bearing inside of it and wore the roller on the outside on one spot just a touch and the bastard will not spin, now not all the lifters suffered from such, as the ones that rolled a bit I believe were fine, it's the same with some Truck gearboxes the needle bearings have to move and roll around a bit or they will not last regardless.
Oil mainly only stops the metal from touching and dirt and fuel and water etc are what causes the grit between the oil and that is what causes the wearing out regardless, so a mate had a New KTM 380 2 Stroke and after a long week end I dropped my engine oil on the dirt and so did 4 others the same but the KTM bloke said no he uses the best synthetic so it needs not to be changed he claimed, well we got him to drain it and when we came back to his bike their was a pyramid of metal like you would not believe sitting on the dirt, I said their you go ! your bike does not have a oil filter so regardless what metal is in your oil is going to cut loose inside, I used auto transmission oil in my 2 strokes it's cheap and I just drop the basted freely every 2ed month or so.
I have heard turbo bearings rattle or even a stupid winding noise going up and down, such as that can be cured with using different oils that will make a rattling type or a noisy winding noise turbo, just disappear directly.
A roller or ball bearing when you think about it, if it does not spin you are wearing only a % of the bearing, but if she rolls you use all of the bearing surface.